情报科学 ›› 2021, Vol. 39 ›› Issue (2): 169-177.

• 博士论坛 • 上一篇    下一篇

融合Altmetrics和引文分析的期刊影响力综合评价研究

  


  • 出版日期:2021-02-01 发布日期:2021-03-11

  • Online:2021-02-01 Published:2021-03-11

摘要:

【目的/意义】为提高评价体系的全面性和系统性,本研究融合了Altmetrics和引文分析法构建期刊影响力
评价体系,并对国际图情期刊的影响力进行分析,提出可行性建议,进一步促进图情期刊的可持续发展。【方法/过
程】本研究以2017版JCR报告及Altmetric Explorer平台提供的国际图情期刊为样本构建期刊影响力综合评价体
系,并分析国际图情期刊的影响力排名、维度相关性及期刊二维分布。【结果/结论】两平台共获取相关指标26个,筛
选出可用指标19个,分属于正式和非正式科学交流影响力两个维度,且非正式科学交流影响力对综合影响力起补
充作用,期刊载文量大小、发刊频率、成果的专业性、是否容易获取等因素会对期刊影响力产生作用。【创新/局限】
Altmetrics相关理论与方法尚未发展成熟,未来仍需各界学者的关注。

Abstract:

【Purpose/significance】In order to make the evaluation system more comprehensive and systematic, this study integrates
Altmetrics with citation analysis to construct an evaluation system of Journal influence, which is applied to the international journals of
Library and Information Science. Then the feasibility suggestions are put forward to promote the sustainable development of informa⁃
tion journals.【Method/process】This study constructed a systematic comprehensive evaluation system of journal influence based on
the international information journals samples of JCR report of the 2017 edition and Altmetric Explorer platform, and analyzed the
ranking, dimension correlation and two-dimensional distribution of them.【Result/conclusion】Twenty-six relevant indicators were ob⁃
tained from the two platforms, and 19 available indicators were screened out, which belong to the two dimensions of formal and infor⁃
mal scientific communication influence. Informal scientific communication influence plays a supplementary role in the comprehensive
influence. The size of journal papers, the frequency of publication, the professionalism of academic achievements, and whether they
are easy to obtain all affected journal influence.【Innovation/limitation】Theories and methods related to Altmetrics are not yet mature
which need the attention of scholars in the future.