情报科学 ›› 2025, Vol. 43 ›› Issue (4): 1-12.

• 专论 •    下一篇

基于“主题—工具—效力”三维框架的我国传统村落 保护政策研究

  

  • 出版日期:2025-04-05 发布日期:2025-08-28

  • Online:2025-04-05 Published:2025-08-28

摘要: 【目的/意义】在我国传统村落保护政策稳步实施的过程中,探究政策特征和存在的不完善之处,对未来政策 制定与优化具有重要参考价值。【方法/过程】构建我国传统村落“政策主题—政策工具—政策效力”三维分析框架, 运用LDA主题建模、内容分析法和PMC指数模型,借助pyLDAvis、Nvivo20等软件,对我国2012年8月22日—2024 年5月8日发布的126份传统村落保护政策文本进行多维量化评价。【结果/结论】研究表明,我国传统村落保护政策 总体质量较优,能够较好满足当下传统村落保护发展工作实际,但政策主题条款有待进一步细化,政策工具使用结 构失衡,政策效力仍留有较大提升空间。对此,提出均衡政策工具内外“双向”结构组合和全方位“无遗漏”优化政 策效力的改进建议。【创新/局限】搭建传统村落保护政策“主题—工具—效力”三维分析框架,从多维有效量化评估 我国现有的传统村落保护政策。未来,可扩大政策文本研究量,进行更为细致、详尽的探讨。

Abstract: 【Purpose/significance】In the process of steadily implementing the protection policy of traditional villages in China, explor⁃ ing the characteristics and imperfections of the policy has important reference value for future policy formulation and optimization. 【Method/process】The three-dimensional analysis framework of "policy theme - policy tool - policy effectiveness" in Chinese tradi⁃ tional villages was constructed, using LDA theme modeling, content analysis and PMC index model, and using pyLDAvis, Nvivo20 and other software. This paper makes a quantitative evaluation of 126 traditional village protection policy texts published from August 22, 2012 to May 8, 2024.【Result/conclusion】The research shows that the overall quality of China's traditional village protection policy is relatively good, which can better meet the current practical work of traditional village protection and development. However, the policy theme provisions need to be further refined, the use of policy tools is unbalanced, and the policy effectiveness still has a large room for improvement. In this regard, the paper puts forward some suggestions to optimize the effectiveness of balanced policy tools by combin⁃ ing internal and external "two-way" structure and "no omissions" in all aspects.【Innovation/limitation】To build a three-dimensional analysis framework of "subject-tool-effectiveness" of traditional village protection policy, and evaluate the existing traditional village protection policy in China effectively and quantitatively from multiple dimensions. In the future, the amount of research on policy texts can be expanded to carry out more detailed and detailed discussions.