生态水保措施对中国典型区域水土流失的影响:Meta分析

doi:10.16843/j.sswc.2023053

Abstract
Figure/Table
References
Related Citation (15)

Download: PDF (1342 KB) HTML (1 KB)
Export: BibTeX | EndNote (RIS)

Abstract [Background] As one of the most serious environmental issues in the world, soil erosion causes water pollution, reservoir siltation, soil productivity decline, thus threatens agricultural systems and even affects global climate. The benefits of ecological soil and water conservation measures (ESWCMs, such as micro basins tillage and contour tillage) are widely understood, including runoff and soil loss reducing to a certain extent when compared with traditional tillage. While few studies have focused on China’s different soil types and erosion characteristics. [Methods] We reviewed literature from Web of Science, Scopus, and China National Knowledge Infrastructure using terms like "Conservation practice" "Contour tillage" "Runoff" "Sediment" "Erosion" and "China" and retained literatures based on criteria such as natural or simulated precipitation, runoff or soil loss data, reported replications and statistics, recorded factors like location and slope, and at least two data pairs per group. Ultimately, 49 literatures were selected to quantify the impacts on different ESWCMs and identify the slope and precipitation for the greatest runoff and sediment reduction by calculating the log response ratio (LRR). [Results] The three regions’ soil and water conservation benefits varied due to the differences in climate, terrain, and soil properties: 1) ESWCMs applied in the black soil region of Northeast China were the most effective in reducing runoff and soil loss (66.65% runoff and 75.83% sediment), followed by those applied in the purple soil region of Southwest China (39.98% runoff and 58.30% sediment) and loess soil region of Northwest China (16.36% runoff and 32.44% sediment). 2) Micro basins tillage (MBT) (71.79% runoff and 87.03% sediment) no-tillage with mulch (NTM) (17.30% runoff and 32.51% sediment), collecting soil to form a ridge with no-till (CSNT) (55.78% runoff and 71.36% sediment reduction) were the most efficient soil and water conservation measures in controlling water erosion in the black soil of Northeast China, the loess soil region of Northwest China and the purple soil region of Southwest China, respectively. 3) The slope gradients ranged from 0-3°, >3°-5° and >10°-15° (0-3°: 97.09%; >3°-5°: 74.62%; and >10°-15°: 39.41%) caused the largest reduction of runoff in the black soil region of Northeast China, the loess soil region of Northwest China, and the purple soil region of Southwest China. Meanwhile, the effects of sediment reduction were the most obvious, ranging from 0-3°, >10°-15°, and >20°-25° (0-3°: 89.32%; >10°-15°: 75.94%; and >20°-25°: 67.25%). 4) The effect of ESWCMs under rainstorms was the most obvious in the black soil region of Northeast China. The effect on runoff reduction under light rain in the purple soil region of Southwest China was the most obvious, but it failed to pass the significance test in sediment reduction. [Conclusions] The results provided optimal conservation tillage measures for three regions, different slopes and different rainfalls, and provided data support for reducing regional soil and water loss in China.

Key words： ecological soil and water conservation measures runoff sediment water erosion region

Received: 23 February 2023

PACS:

S157

Fund:Science and Technology Major Project of Tibetan Autonomous Region of China(XZ202201ZD0005G02),National Natural Science Foundation of China (42277353) and Chengdu Science and Technology Project(2022-YF05-01162-SN)

Corresponding Authors: ZHOU Ping(1981-),female,doctor of philosophy,associate professor.Main research interests:Soil erosion.E-mail:zp09@imde.ac.cn E-mail: zp09@imde.ac.cn

	Service

	E-mail this article
	Add to my bookshelf
	Add to citation manager
	E-mail Alert
	RSS
	Articles by authors
	LI Mingming
	XU Guangzhi
	YANG Kaicheng
	DAI Fuqiang
	ZHOU Ping

Cite this article:

LI Mingming,XU Guangzhi,YANG Kaicheng, et al. Effects of ecological soil and water conservation measures on soil erosion control in China’s typical regions: A meta-analysis[J]. SSWC, 2024, 22(6): 163-175.

URL:

http://journal12.magtechjournal.com/Jweb_stbc/EN/10.16843/j.sswc.2023053 OR http://journal12.magtechjournal.com/Jweb_stbc/EN/Y2024/V22/I6/163

[1]	BORRELLI P, ROBINSON D A, FLEISCHER L R, et al. An assessment of the global impact of 21st century land use change on soil erosion [J]. Nature Communications, 2017, 8(2013): 1.
[2]	CEVASCO A, PEPE G, BRANDOLINI P. The influences of geological and land use settings on shallow landslides triggered by an intense rainfall event in a coastal terraced environment [J]. Bulletin of Engineering Geology and the Environment, 2014, 73(3): 859.
[3]	MONTGOMERY D R. Soil erosion and agricultural sustainability [J]. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 2007, 104(33): 13268.
[4]	FU Bojie, ZHAO Wenwu, CHEN Liding, et al. Assessment of soil erosion at large watershed scale using RUSLE and GIS: A case study in the Loess Plateau of China [J]. Land Degradation & Development, 2005, 16(1): 73.
[5]	POESEN J. Soil erosion in the anthropocene: Research needs [J]. Earth Surface Processes and Landforms, 2018, 43(1): 64.
[6]	POLOCZANSKA E S, BROWN C J, SYDEMAN W J, et al. Global imprint of climate change on marine life [J]. Nature Climate Change, 2013, 3(10): 919.
[7]	WEI Wei, CHEN Liding, YANG Lei, et al. Spatial scale effects of water erosion dynamics: Complexities, variabilities, and uncertainties [J]. Chinese Geographical Science, 2012, 22(2): 127.
[8]	LI Mian, YAO Wenyi, SHEN Zhenzhou, et al. Erosion rates of different land uses and sediment sources in a watershed using the Cs-137 tracing method: Field studies in the Loess Plateau of China [J]. Environmental Earth Sciences, 2016, 75(7): 591.
[9]	LIZAGA I, QUIJANO L, GASPAR L, et al. Linking land use changes to variation in soil properties in a Mediterranean mountain agroecosystem [J]. Catena, 2019, 172: 516.
[10]	PIMENTEL D. Soil erosion: A food and environmental threat [J]. Environment, Development and Sustainability, 2006, 8(1): 119.
[11]	WANG X, CAMMERAAT E L H, ROMEIJN P, et al. Soil organic carbon redistribution by water erosion: The role of CO2 emissions for the carbon budget [J]. PLOS One, 2014, 9(5): e96299.
[12]	HUMBERTO B R L. Principles of soil conservation and management [M]. Heidelberg: Springer Dordrecht, 2010: 61.
[13]	GUO Shufang, ZHAI Limei, LIU Jian, et al. Cross-ridge tillage decreases nitrogen and phosphorus losses from sloping farmlands in southern hilly regions of China [J]. Soil & Tillage Research, 2019, 191: 48.
[14]	JIA Lizhi, ZHAO Wenwu, ZHAI Rujie, et al. Regional differences in the soil and water conservation efficiency of conservation tillage in China [J]. Catena, 2019, 175: 18.
[15]	SUI Yuanyuan, YANG Ou, YAN Baixing, et al. Assessment of micro-basin tillage as a soil and water conservation practice in the black soil region of Northeast China [J]. Plos One, 2016, 11(3): e0152313.
[16]	SUN Yanni, ZENG Yongjun, SHI Qinghua, et al. No-tillage controls on runoff: A meta-analysis [J]. Soil & Tillage Research, 2015, 153: 1.
[17]	ZHANG Jianhui, FRIELINGHAUS M, TIAN Guanglong, et al. Ridge and contour tillage effects on soil erosion from steep hillslopes in the Sichuan Basin, China [J]. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation, 2004, 59(6): 277.
[18]	LAL R, BRUCE J P. The potential of world cropland soils to sequester C and mitigate the greenhouse effect [J]. Environmental Science & Policy, 1999, 2(2): 177.
[19]	OBOUR A K, MIKHA M M, HOLMAN J D, et al. Changes in soil surface chemistry after fifty years of tillage and nitrogen fertilization [J]. Geoderma, 2017, 308: 46.
[20]	JIA Lizhi, ZHAO Wenwu, ZHAI Ruijie, et al. Quantifying the effects of contour tillage in controlling water erosion in China: A meta-analysis [J]. Catena, 2020, 195(1): 104829.
[21]	CHEN Jia, XIAO Haibing, LI Zhongwu, et al. Threshold effects of vegetation coverage on soil erosion control in small watersheds of the red soil hilly region in China [J]. Ecological Engineering, 2019, 132: 109.
[22]	CHEN Die, WEI Wei, CHEN Liding. Effects of terracing practices on water erosion control in China: A meta analysis [J]. Earth-Science Reviews, 2017, 173: 109.
[23]	CHEN Die, WEI Wei, CHEN Liding. How can terracing impact on soil moisture variation in China? A meta-analysis [J]. Agricultural Water Management, 2020, 227: 105849.
[24]	HU Jian, LU Yihe, FU Bojie, et al. Quantifying the effect of ecological restoration on runoff and sediment yields: A meta-analysis for the Loess Plateau of China [J]. Progress in Physical Geography-Earth and Environment, 2017, 41(6): 753.
[25]	MAETENS W, VANMAERCKE M, POESEN J, et al. Effects of land use on annual runoff and soil loss in Europe and the Mediterranean: A meta-analysis of plot data [J]. Progress in Physical Geography-Earth and Environment, 2012, 36(5): 599.
[26]	MARTÍNEZ I G, PRAT C, OVALLE C, et al. Subsoiling improves conservation tillage in cereal production of severely degraded Alfisols under Mediterranean climate [J]. Geoderma, 2012, 189: 10.
[27]	XIONG Muqi, SUN Ranhao, CHEN Liding. Effects of soil conservation techniques on water erosion control: A global analysis [J]. Science of the Total Environment, 2018, 645: 753.
[28]	GUREVITCH J, KORICHEVA J, NAKAGAWA S, et al. Meta-analysis and the science of research synthesis [J]. Nature, 2018, 555(7695): 175.
[29]	MALLEN-COOPER M, NAKAGAWA S, ELDRIDGE D J. Global meta-analysis of soil-disturbing vertebrates reveals strong effects on ecosystem patterns and processes [J]. Global Ecology and Biogeography, 2019, 28(5): 661.
[30]	GIBSON L, LEE T M, KOH L P, et al. Primary forests are irreplaceable for sustaining tropical biodiversity [J]. Nature, 2011, 478(7369): 378.
[31]	EHIGIATOR O A, ANYATA B U. Effects of land clearing techniques and tillage systems on runoff and soil erosion in a tropical rain forest in Nigeria [J]. Journal of Environmental Management, 2011, 92(11): 2875.
[32]	GOE M R. Influence of slope and stone cover on tillage operations in the Ethiopian highlands [J]. Soil & Tillage Research, 1999, 49(4): 289.
[33]	LIU Ruiming, ZHANG Peipei, WANG Xiujuan, et al. Assessment of effects of best management practices on agricultural non-point source pollution in Xiangxi River watershed [J]. Agricultural Water Management, 2013, 117: 9.
[34]	XU Haichao, JIA Lizhi, ZHANG Jianhui, et al. Combined effects of tillage direction and slope gradient on soil translocation by hoeing [J]. Catena, 2019, 175: 421.
[35]	XIAO Bo, WANG Qinghai, WANG Huifang, et al. The effects of grass hedges and micro-basins on reducing soil and water loss in temperate regions: A case study of Northern China [J]. Soil & Tillage Research, 2012, 122: 22.
[36]	MADARÁSZ B, JAKAB G, SZALAI Z, et al. Long-term effects of conservation tillage on soil erosion in central Europe: A random forest-based approach [J]. Soil & Tillage Research, 2021, 209: 104959.
[37]	JAHN R, BLUME H P, ASIO V B, et al. Guidelines for soil description, 4th edition [M]. Rome: Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, 2006: 32.
[38]	VIECHTBAUER W. Conducting meta-analyses in R with the metafor package [J]. Journal of Statistical Software, 2010, 36(3): 1.
[39]	MARTINEZ I, OVALLE C, POZO A D, et al. Influence of conservation tillage and soil water content on crop yield in dryland compacted alfisol of central chile [J]. Chilean Journal of Agricultural Research, 2011, 71(4): 615.
[40]	WEI Wei, CHEN Die, WANG Liding, et al. Global synthesis of the classifications, distributions, benefits and issues of terracing [J]. Earth-Science Reviews, 2016, 159: 388.
[41]	VERMANG J, MARCO A, SILVA D, et al. Characterization of soil surface roughness effects on runoff and soil erosion rates under simulated Rainfall [J]. Soil Science Society of America Journal, 2015, 79(3): 903.
[42]	ZHANG Rui. Analysis and zoning of Cropping pattern in black soil region of Northeast China [D]. Haerbin, Heilongjiang: Northeast Agricultural University, 2022: 46.
[43]	SONG Jie. Study on water and nitrogen transport in purple soil under typical maize and wheat rotation system in southwest hilly region [D]. Mianyang, Sichuan: Southwest University of Science and Technology, 2022: 28.
[44]	CHEN Dingye. Effects of farmres' planting behavior on soil and water loss [D]. Wuhan, Hubei: Huazhong agricultural university, 2019: 72.
[45]	WIYO K A, KASOMEKERA Z M, FEYen J. Effect of tied-ridging on soil water status of a maize crop under Malawi conditions [J]. Agricultural Water Management, 2000, 45(2): 101.
[46]	SHEN Changpu, LIU Fu, ZHANG Shiling, et al. Mathematic model and its examination of the optimum block space on ridge plotted sloping field [J]. Bulletin of Soil and Water Conservation, 1997(3): 4.
[47]	LIU Yifan, DUNKERLEY D, LÓPEZ-VICENTE M, et al. Trade-off between surface runoff and soil erosion during the implementation of ecological restoration programs in semiarid regions: A meta-analysis [J]. Science of the Total Environment, 2020, 712: 136477.
[48]	VIAN J F, PEIGNE J, CHAUSSOD R, et al. Effects of four tillage systems on soil structure and soil microbial biomass in organic farming [J]. Soil Use and Management, 2009, 25(1): 1.
[49]	YUAN Xiping, LEI Tingwu. Soil and water conservation measures and their benefits in runoff and sediment reductions [J]. Transactions of the CSAE, 2004, 20(2): 296.
[50]	TAROLLI P, PRETI F, ROMANO N. Terraced landscapes: From an old best practice to a potential hazard for soil degradation due to land abandonment [J]. Anthropocene, 2014, 6: 10.
[51]	CHEN Jing, CHEN Di, LIU Shunguo. The impact of conservation tillage on soil quality and its comprehensive benefits [J]. Agricultural Economy, 2022(12): 12.
[52]	ZHOU Shiming, ZHOU Xiong. The significance and promotion strategies of implementing conservation tillage technology in farmland [J]. Scientific Breeding, 2021(2): 5.
[53]	HU Lifeng. Yield effects of conservation tillage experiments in China [J]. Journal of Northeast Agricultural Sciences, 2020, 45(4): 40.
[54]	JIANG Fangshi, HUANG Yanhe, WANG Mingkuang, et al. Effects of rainfall intensity and slope gradient on steep colluvial deposit erosion in Southeast China [J]. Soil Science Society of America Journal, 2014, 78(5): 1741.
[55]	YONG Xu, BO Yang, QING Tang, et al. Analysis of comprehensive benefits of transforming slope farmland to terraces on the Loess Plateau: A case study of the Yangou Watershed in northern Shaanxi province, China [J]. Journal of Mountain Science, 2011, 8(3): 448.
[56]	TAO Wanghai, WU Junhu. Study on numerical simulation of slope runoff and sediment yield rule [J]. Journal of Soil and Water Conservation, 2016, 30(1): 54.
[57]	LI Tianhong, GAO Yuan. Runoff and sediment yield variations in response to precipitation changes: A case study of Xichuan Watershed in the Loess Plateau, China [J]. Water (Switzerland), 2015, 7(10): 5638.
[58]	WU Lei, PENG Mengling, QIAO Shanshan, et al. Effects of rainfall intensity and slope gradient on runoff and sediment yield characteristics of bare loess soil [J]. Environmental Science and Pollution Research, 2018, 25(4): 3480.
[59]	MA Bo, LI Chaodong, LI Zhanbin, et al. Effects of crops on runoff and soil loss on sloping farmland under simulated rainfall [J]. Clean-Soil Air Water, 2016, 44(7): 849.
[60]	XIE Zhenghui, SU Fengge, LIANG Xu, et al. Applications of a surface runoff model with horton and dunne runoff for VIC [J]. Advances in Atmospheric Sciences, 2003, 20(2): 165.
[61]	NGUYEN V B, NGUYEN Q B, ZHANG Yongwei, et al. Effect of particle size on erosion characteristics [J]. Wear, 2016, 348: 126.
[62]	CHENG Qinjuan, CAI Qiangguo. Splash erosion by raindrops in typical soil and water loss regions of China [J]. Bulletin of Soil and Water Conservation, 2010, 30(1): 17.
[63]	HONKANEN H, TURTOLA E, LEMOLA R, et al. Response of boreal clay soil properties and erosion to ten years of no-till management [J]. Soil & Tillage Research, 2021, 212: 105043.
[64]	ZHANG Wencan, GREGORY A S, WHALLEY W R, et al. Characteristics of soil organic matter within an erosional landscape under agriculture in Northeast China: stock, source, and thermal stability [J]. Soil & Tillage Research, 2021, 209: 104927.